WP4 and its Outputs
This page presents the project’s Work Packages (WPs) and the results obtained. You can access detailed information about the research, analyses, and findings carried out during the project, as well as the latest updates related to the project.
Teacher Guide and STEM Lesson Plans
Within the scope of WP4, 5 different STEM lesson plans focusing on renewable energy and sustainability themes have been prepared for teachers. These plans are designed to enhance energy literacy, support experiential learning, and encourage teachers to use innovative pedagogical approaches.
The prepared STEM plans include structured lesson plans aligned with learning outcomes, detailed teaching materials, classroom-ready educational resources, implementation guides, and interactive educational games. Each plan integrates theoretical content with practical activities, promoting problem-solving and collaborative learning. Additionally, the plans include experiment designs, small-scale renewable energy applications, scenario-based activities, and assessment tools.
The materials have been prepared for direct classroom use by teachers and are supported with clear instructions, activity flows, and assessment sections. All prepared content has been translated into English as well as the partner countries’ languages (Turkish, Portuguese, Greek, and Macedonian) to ensure international accessibility and widespread use. Thanks to the multilingual structure, the content can be directly implemented in consortium countries and adapted to different educational contexts.
GREENLIGHT Teacher Guide and STEM Lesson Plans can be downloaded from the links below.
- 📄 Teacher Guide – Five STEM Lesson Plans Handbook (Turkish)
- 📄 Teacher Guide – Five STEM Lesson Plans Handbook (English)
- 📄 Teacher Guide – Five STEM Lesson Plans Handbook (Greek)
- 📄 Teacher Guide – Five STEM Lesson Plans Handbook (Portuguese)
- 📄 Teacher Guide – Five STEM Lesson Plans Handbook (Macedonian)
Student Worksheets
Within the scope of WP4, 5 different Student Worksheets have been prepared to complement the teacher guides. These materials are designed to support students in learning about renewable energy, energy efficiency, and sustainability through active participation. The worksheets include structured activities that enable students to transform conceptual knowledge into practical application.
The prepared content consists of problem-solving tasks, analysis and interpretation activities, scenario-based applications, research questions, and assessment sections. Each worksheet has been developed in direct alignment with the related STEM lesson plan and aims to enhance students’ critical thinking, decision-making, and ability to make informed choices regarding sustainable energy.
The materials are structured with clear instructions, visual supports, and implementation steps that accommodate different learning styles. They are also designed as part of a comprehensive learning set that enables teachers to systematically guide classroom practices.
All prepared Student Worksheets have been translated into English as well as the partner countries’ languages for international accessibility. Accordingly, the materials are available in Turkish, Portuguese, Greek, and Macedonian, making them directly applicable in consortium countries and adaptable to different educational settings.
You can download the GREENLIGHT Student Worksheets from the links below.
Teacher Training Seminars and Evaluation Results of Lesson Plans
Within the scope of the Greenlight project, energy and environment-themed lesson plans were developed for students aged 15–17. In order to evaluate the effectiveness of these lesson plans, pilot implementations were carried out by teachers working in Portugal, Türkiye, and North Macedonia. To support this pilot phase, face-to-face teacher training seminars were organized in all three countries. To access news about the training seminars conducted in Türkiye, Portugal, and North Macedonia, please click on.
The main objective of these training seminars was to equip teachers with the necessary knowledge and skills to effectively implement the developed lesson plans and accompanying student worksheets in their classrooms. The seminars were structured to provide both theoretical knowledge and practical application opportunities for participants.
The training seminars were organized separately in each country, where teachers gathered in person at their schools or universities. Each seminar consisted of three main sessions. In the first session, participants were provided with comprehensive information about the project and the developed materials. In the second session, teachers were asked to evaluate the lesson plans based on criteria such as scientific accuracy, pedagogical adequacy, curriculum alignment, and sustainability. At the end of the third session, participants completed an online survey to provide feedback on both the seminar process and the materials they analyzed.
A total of 78 teachers from the three countries participated in the training seminars. While the distribution of participants across countries was relatively balanced, differences were observed in gender distribution. Female teachers constituted the majority in North Macedonia and Portugal, whereas male teachers were more predominant in Türkiye. The age range of participants generally varied from under 30 to 59 years old; however, in Portugal, more than one-third of the teachers were over the age of 60.
An analysis of teachers’ self-assessments regarding their expertise in energy and environmental topics revealed a decreasing trend in the combined “Good” and “Very Good” categories from Türkiye to Portugal and North Macedonia. Approximately 50% of teachers in Portugal and North Macedonia rated their expertise as “moderate.”
For the overall evaluation of the lesson plans, teachers were asked to rate six criteria using a five-point Likert scale ranging from “Completely Inadequate” to “Completely Adequate.” More than 87% of teachers in North Macedonia rated the lesson plans and supporting materials (e.g., worksheets) as “Adequate” or “Completely Adequate.” In Portugal, this rate ranged between 66% and 85%. Teachers in Türkiye provided comparatively lower ratings, with some participants evaluating all criteria as “Completely Inadequate.”
Regarding the item measuring motivational impact (Item B), a limited number of “Completely Inadequate” responses were observed across all countries. Nevertheless, overall findings indicate a strong tendency toward positive perceptions of the lesson plans’ contribution to the teaching and learning process.
In terms of future use, teachers in North Macedonia demonstrated the highest willingness to use the lesson plans beyond the scope of the Greenlight project. They were followed by their counterparts in Greece and Portugal. Teachers highlighted several reasons for their intention to use the materials, including their ability to effectively combine theory and practice, support student learning and understanding, accelerate mastery of content, provide well-structured and comprehensive content, and offer engaging, student-centered activities that promote environmental awareness.
Overall, the feedback indicates that both the training seminars and the developed materials were perceived as highly useful, practical, and well-structured, contributing to more effective teaching and learning experiences.
However, some teachers expressed concerns regarding the limited duration allocated for each lesson, the extensive scope of the lesson plan set, and the time required for implementation. These factors were seen as potential challenges for alignment with existing curricula. This concern was particularly emphasized in vocational education contexts, where the applicability of the materials may depend on the specific subject area.
Additionally, some teachers noted that the number of activities planned for a single lesson was too high and recommended allocating more time to ensure effective implementation. A few participants from Türkiye expressed reservations about computer-based tasks and the use of videos, suggesting instead the inclusion of more interactive and game-based learning activities.
In conclusion, the lesson plans and training seminars developed under WP4 were generally evaluated positively by teachers and demonstrated high potential for implementation across different educational contexts, with minor improvements required.
For detailed data and country-based analyses, please click on the file headings below.
GREENLIGHT Teacher Training Seminars Report can be downloaded from the links below.
Green Energy STEAM Workshops
The Green Energy STEAM Workshops developed within the scope of the GREENLIGHT project were jointly implemented in the three partner countries with the aim of improving students' knowledge of renewable energy, energy efficiency, sustainability and environmental awareness. Throughout the implementation process, all partners followed the same implementation plan, applied the same knowledge tests and adopted the same evaluation methodology. The findings obtained from all partner countries were consolidated into a joint comparative evaluation report. A total of 120 students participated in the comparative evaluation process. Of these participants, 67 were from Portugal, 28 from Türkiye, and 25 from North Macedonia. All students successfully completed the pre-test, post-test and post-implementation evaluation processes. The analyses were conducted based on 120 pre-tests, 120 post-tests, and 120 feedback forms. A common 43-item assessment framework was used for knowledge evaluation across all partner countries.
Throughout the STEAM workshops, students actively participated in inquiry-based learning, digital activities, group work, hands-on experiments, presentations, poster preparation, video production, quizzes and problem-solving activities. During the evaluation process, the same students completed matched knowledge tests before and after the implementation. Open-ended questions were not included in the knowledge scoring, and common evaluation criteria were applied across all participating countries. This approach ensured the creation of a directly comparable common dataset among the partner countries.
The joint analysis demonstrates that the GREENLIGHT STEAM Workshops made a significant contribution to improving students' energy literacy and environmental knowledge. Considering all participants together, the average knowledge test score increased from 31.98/43 (74.4%) to 35.02/43 (81.4%), representing an average improvement of 3.03 points and 7.1 percentage points. Overall, 81 students (67.5%) improved their pre-test scores, 10 students maintained the same score, while 29 students achieved lower scores in the post-test. Furthermore, the number of students achieving 80% or higher increased from 44 to 69 by the end of the implementation.
At the country level, the highest post-test average was achieved in Türkiye (84.4%), which also recorded the greatest improvement with an increase of 13.5 percentage points. In Portugal, the average score increased from 78.7% to 82.5%, corresponding to an improvement of 3.8 percentage points, mainly due to the relatively high baseline performance. In North Macedonia, the average achievement increased from 66.8% to 75.3%, while 22 out of 25 students (88%) improved their knowledge scores, representing the highest individual improvement rate among the three partner countries.
When the knowledge domains were analysed separately, considerable improvements were observed across all countries, particularly in renewable energy technologies and application-based learning. The highest improvement in both Türkiye and North Macedonia was recorded in the Technology and Applications domain, with increases of 16.8 and 16.2 percentage points, respectively. In Portugal, the greatest improvement was observed in the Basic Concepts and Sustainability domain, with an increase of 10.2 percentage points. In addition, positive learning gains were achieved across all partner countries in the areas of energy efficiency, climate, photovoltaic systems, hydroelectric applications and biogas. The findings further indicate that technology-based learning activities made a substantial contribution to students' conceptual understanding.
The joint evaluations conducted following the implementation demonstrate that the STEAM lesson plans and learning materials developed within the GREENLIGHT project were evaluated very positively across all partner countries. Considering the six evaluation indicators together, the average ratings for lesson and material quality were calculated as 4.02/5 in Portugal, 4.11/5 in Türkiye and 4.77/5 in North Macedonia. The highest-rated indicator was scientific accuracy (4.18/5) in Portugal, worksheet readability (4.29/5) in Türkiye and worksheet readability (4.88/5) in North Macedonia. Furthermore, the positive evaluation rate exceeded 92.9% across all indicators assessed in all participating countries.
The findings related to student satisfaction also reveal consistently strong results. In Portugal, 94% of students rated classroom participation as "good" or "very good", while in Türkiye the positive evaluation rate reached 71.4% across the dimensions of overall lesson quality, learning experience and creative thinking. In North Macedonia, positive evaluation rates ranged between 92% and 100% across all student outcome indicators. These findings demonstrate that the STEAM activities developed within the project generated a high level of student satisfaction across different educational systems.
The evaluation of the activities further indicates that students showed particularly strong interest in hands-on learning experiences. In Portugal, the average score for participation in the activities was 4.21/5, while the perceived learning impact reached 4.16/5. In Türkiye, the corresponding averages were 3.26/5 for participation and 3.45/5 for learning impact. North Macedonia achieved the highest ratings, with average scores of 4.79/5 for participation and 4.86/5 for learning impact. The perceived difficulty level of the activities remained low across all partner countries, with average difficulty scores of 1.98/5 in Portugal, 2.43/5 in Türkiye and 1.53/5 in North Macedonia.
Students' open-ended feedback demonstrates that group work, hands-on activities, problem-solving, inquiry-based learning, digital content creation, poster preparation, video production and the integration of real-life examples made significant contributions to the learning process. Students particularly appreciated connecting renewable energy, energy conservation, environmental protection and sustainable living with everyday life. For future implementations, they recommended including more experiments, physical models, visual learning materials, practical activities and short knowledge reinforcement exercises.
The comparative implementations carried out across the three partner countries demonstrate that the Green Energy STEAM Workshops developed within the GREENLIGHT project successfully improved students' knowledge levels, strengthened their energy literacy and increased their awareness of sustainability-related issues. When the pre-test and post-test results, teaching materials, classroom activities and student feedback are considered together, the findings indicate that the instructional approach developed within the project can be successfully implemented across different educational environments. Based on the recommendations presented in the report, future implementations should continue using common evaluation instruments, further expand application-based STEAM activities and enrich digital learning materials in order to enhance learning outcomes.
Detailed versions of the comparative evaluation report on the Green Energy STEAM Workshops implemented within the GREENLIGHT project are available in the following languages.
The report presents the methodology, pre-test and post-test analyses, student feedback, comparative country results and recommendations derived from the Green Energy STEAM Workshops implemented in Türkiye, Portugal and North Macedonia within the framework of the GREENLIGHT WP4.4 activities.